The catalytic converter is a crucial part of your exhaust system, converting harmful exhaust gases into less harmful substances. Without a working catalytic converter, your car will fail its MOT inspection and you risk hefty fines. In this comprehensive guide, you'll learn when your catalytic converter needs replacing, the costs at FAAY Auto Groep, the alternatives, and how to prevent catalytic converter theft.
What Does a Catalyst Do?
The catalytic converter (or "cat") is an emission control system in your exhaust that converts toxic gases into less harmful substances. The device contains precious metals (platinum, palladium, rhodium) that act as catalysts in chemical reactions.
How Does a Catalyst Work?
At temperatures of 400-800°C, three chemical reactions take place:
- Oxidation CO: Carbon monoxide (CO) is converted into carbon dioxide (CO2)
- Oxidation HC: Unburned hydrocarbons (HC) are converted into CO2 and H2O
- NOx Reduction: Nitrogen oxides (NOx) are converted into nitrogen (N2) and oxygen (O2)
Result: Toxic gas emissions decrease by 90-95%. Modern catalytic converters are so effective that exhaust fumes are cleaner than the air in many cities.
Why is Catalytic Converter Legally Required?
Since 1993, all new gasoline cars in Europe have been required to be equipped with catalytic converters. Diesel cars followed later. The reason: protecting air quality and public health.
- CO (carbon monoxide): Toxic gas, prevents oxygen absorption in blood
- HC (hydrocarbons): Carcinogenic
- NOx (nitrogen oxides): Causes smog and respiratory diseases
Cars without a (working) catalytic converter are immediately rejected during the MOT inspection.
Symptoms of a defective catalytic converter
A broken or clogged catalytic converter causes several symptoms:
1. Exhaust Smells Strange
Normal exhaust smells faintly of combustion products. A defective catalytic converter causes:
- Rotten egg smell: Sulphur-containing compounds are not converted
- Very sharp fuel smell: Unburned fuel passes through catalytic converter
- Chemical smell: Incomplete conversion causes unusual odors
2. Loss of power
A clogged catalytic converter creates back pressure in the exhaust system. The engine can't get rid of exhaust gases. Result:
- Engine feels weak, especially when accelerating
- Low power at high revs
- Car responds slowly to accelerating
- Maximum speed lower than normal
A severely clogged catalytic converter can even cause the engine to stall.
3. Increased Fuel Consumption
The engine has to work harder to overcome back pressure. The lambda sensor also reacts to incomplete conversion and adjusts the engine's fuel/air mixture. This increases consumption by 15-25%.
4. Engine Light On
Lambda sensors before and after the catalytic converter measure their effectiveness. If the catalytic converter is malfunctioning, the ECU detects this and activates the engine light. Common error codes:
- P0420: Catalyst efficiency below threshold (bank 1)
- P0430: Catalyst efficiency below threshold (bank 2)
- P0421-P0434: Heat catalyst problems
5. Rattling When Accelerating
Internal structure of catalyst (ceramic or metallic honeycomb) may detach due to:
You'll then hear a rattling or clattering noise from the exhaust, especially when accelerating and decelerating. Loose particles further block the flow.
6. Engine Starts Hard or Stalls
A completely clogged catalytic converter can prevent the engine from starting or stalls immediately. Exhaust gases have no escape route, which disrupts the engine's performance.
7. Red-Hot Catalyst
Normally, a catalytic converter reaches temperatures of 400-800°C. In case of problems (misfires, clogged), temperatures can rise to 1,000°C+. Symptoms:
- Catalyst glows red-orange (visible in dark)
- Burning smell under car
- Smoke from base plate
- Heat shield rattles
Danger: An extremely hot catalytic converter can cause a fire. Stop driving immediately if you notice these symptoms.
MOT inspection and catalytic converter
The catalytic converter is an essential part of the MOT inspection. Without a working catalytic converter, your car will immediately fail its inspection.
What is being checked?
During the day APK inspection at FAAY from €17.95 we check:
- Visual inspection: Is the catalytic converter present and correctly installed?
- Emission measurement: CO, HC and NOx within permitted values?
- Lambda value: Fuel/air mixture optimal?
- Condition: No leaks, cracks or serious corrosion?
- OBD readout: No active fault codes related to emissions system?
Emission Requirements Per Fuel Type
| Type | CO (max) | HC (max) | Lambda |
|---|---|---|---|
| Petrol with cat (after 1-1-1993) | 0.3% full | 100 ppm | 0,97-1,03 |
| Petrol without cat (before 1993) | 4.5% full | 1200 ppm | n/a. |
| Diesel (soot measurement) | n/a. | n/a. | K-value < 3.0 |
Cars with catalytic converters have much stricter requirements – without a working catalytic converter you will not achieve these values.
Consequences of a Rejected MOT
If your car fails emissions testing:
- You can return within 14 days for a free re-inspection
- Catalytic converter needs to be repaired or replaced
- After 14 days: pay for new MOT inspection
- Driving with a rejected license plate: €390 fine + possible confiscation of the registration certificate
Manipulation Catalyst: Illegal
Removing or replacing a catalytic converter with an “empty pipe” is punishable:
- Direct MOT rejection
- Fine up to €9,000 upon inspection
- Possible confiscation of vehicle registration certificate
- Insurance may refuse in case of damage (illegal modification)
Don't do it – the risks far outweigh the cost of catalytic converter replacement.
Replacing a catalytic converter: Costs
Costs vary greatly depending on the car, catalytic converter type and choice of original/universal:
Original Catalytic Converter (OEM)
Factory part, perfect fit, highest quality:
- Small cars: €400-€800
- Middle class: €600-€1.200
- Larger cars/SUVs: €800-€1.500
- Premium brands: €1.000-€2.500
- Labor: €100-€250 (1.5-3 hours)
Advantages OEM:
- Perfect fit (no adjustments)
- Highest quality and durability
- Factory warranty
- Optimal performance
Disadvantages OEM:
Universal Catalyst (Aftermarket)
Generic part that is adapted to your car:
- Element: €150-€400
- Labor: €120-€300 (more time due to customization)
- Welding: €50-€100 (if needed)
- Total: €320-€800
Benefits universal:
- Cheaper (30-60% savings)
- Usually in stock
- Meets emission requirements
Disadvantages universal:
- Needs to be modified/welded
- Possibly shorter lifespan
- Quality varies greatly by brand
- Possible minor performance differences
Used Catalyst
Costs: €100-€300 + installation
Risks:
- Unknown lifespan/condition
- May already be partially hidden/worked out
- No guarantee
- Possibly defective again soon
- The MOT inspection can still fail
FAAY advice: Only consider this for very old cars (15+ years old) with low residual value. For newer cars, investing in a new catalytic converter is worthwhile.
Costs Per Car Type (Examples)
| Car | Original | Universal | Labor |
|---|---|---|---|
| VW Polo / Golf | €500-€900 | €200-€400 | €100-€180 |
| Toyota Yaris / Corolla | €600-€1.000 | €250-€450 | €120-€200 |
| Ford Focus / Fiesta | €450-€800 | €200-€400 | €100-€180 |
| BMW 3 Series | €1.000-€1.800 | €400-€700 | €150-€250 |
| Mercedes C-class | €1.200-€2.000 | €450-€800 | €150-€250 |
| Volvo V70 / XC90 | €800-€1.500 | €350-€650 | €140-€220 |
Alternatives: Catalytic Converter Cleaning
Complete replacement isn't always necessary. Sometimes the catalytic converter can be cleaned:
Chemical Cleaning
Method: Special cleaning fluid is guided through the fuel system and cleans the catalytic converter from the inside while driving.
Costs: €50-€120 (product + labor)
Effective for:
- Mild clogging problem
- Recently arisen problem
- Carbon deposits
Not effective for:
- Mechanical damage (loose parts)
- Molten honeycomb
- Severe constipation (years of neglect)
Professional Cleaning (Disassembly)
Method: The catalytic converter is dismantled, flushed with special fluids under pressure, and reinstalled.
Costs: €150-€300
Effectiveness: 60-80% for moderate clogging. At FAAY, we recommend first trying cleaning for cars where a catalytic converter costs over €800.
When to Clean/When Not to Clean?
Cleaning is an option if:
- Catalytic converter relatively new (less than 8 years)
- Problem recently arisen
- No mechanical damage (rattling)
- Emissions just above limit value
Replacement is necessary when:
- Mechanical damage (rattling, loose parts)
- Molten honeycomb (after overheating)
- Severely clogged (engine stalls)
- Cleaning did not help
- Catalyst older than 12-15 years
Prevent Catalytic Converter Theft
Catalytic converter theft is a growing problem. Criminals steal catalytic converters for the valuable precious metals (platinum, palladium, rhodium) they contain.
Why Are Catalytic Converters Stolen?
Precious metals in catalysts are extremely valuable:
- Rhodium: €400-€600 per gram
- Palladium: €60-€100 per gram
- Platinum: €30-€50 per gram
A catalytic converter contains 2-7 grams of these metals. Street value: €150-€500. Thieves can cut the catalytic converter loose in 2-5 minutes and sell it to buyers.
Which Cars Are Popular With Thieves?
- Toyota Prius: Highest rhodium content
- Honda Jazz/CR-V: Easily accessible
- Vans (Sprinter, Transit): High ground clearance
- SUVs: Easily accessible without a jack
- Hybrids: Less catalyst used = more precious metal left
Preventing Theft: 8 Tips
1. Park in a garage/closed area
Most effective. Thieves operate on the streets, in parking lots, and along highways.
2. Well-lit places
Park under streetlights or near illuminated buildings. Thieves avoid highly visible locations.
3. Security marking
Have your catalytic converter engraved with the license plate (€30-€60). Marked catalytic converters are harder to sell.
4. Catalytic converter lock/cage
Metal protective cage for the catalytic converter (€150-€400 including installation). This makes theft much more difficult and time-consuming.
5. Alarm with tilt detection
Car alarm that reacts to tilting/lifting of the car. Thieves often use a jack – the alarm goes off.
6. Camera/dashcam
Dashcam with parking mode records activity around the car. Acts as a deterrent if the sticker is visible.
7. Park close to a wall/obstacle
Park as close as possible to a wall, obstacle, or other car. Limit access to the underside of the car.
8. Turning wheels
Turn the front wheels all the way in when parking. This makes crawling under the car more difficult.
Catalyst Stolen: What Now?
- File a report at the police (necessary for insurance)
- Call insurance – often covered under third-party liability insurance
- Do not drive without catalytic converter (engine damage possible)
- Have it towed away to the garage
- Submit a claim with insurance with declaration + quotation
At FAAY we arrange complete handling with insurance and install a new catalytic converter.
Frequently Asked Questions: Catalyst
How long does a catalytic converter last?
Average 120,000-200,000 km or 10-15 years. In good engine condition (no misfires, good spark plugs), a catalytic converter can last 250,000+ km. With poor maintenance, it can fail after just 80,000 km.
Can I drive without a catalytic converter?
Technically yes, but:
- Illegal (fine up to €9,000)
- Direct MOT rejection
- Very harmful to the environment
- Engine may run poorly (lambda sensors receive incorrect data)
- Insurance may refuse
Don't do it – have the catalytic converter replaced immediately by FAAY.
What causes a broken catalytic converter?
Most common causes:
- Misfires: Unburned fuel ignites in catalytic converter (overheating)
- Oil/coolant in exhaust: Blockage and damage
- Bad fuel: Additives damage catalytic converter
- Mechanical damage: Bumps, curb, underbody damage
- Normal wear and tear: Precious metals are depleting
How do I prevent catalytic converter damage?
- Solve misfires immediately (spark plugs, ignition coils)
- Leave regular maintenance doing
- Use good fuel
- Fix oil/coolant leaks
- Avoid hard shocks on the base plate
- Warm up the engine for hard acceleration
What is the average cost of replacing a catalytic converter?
Average price €600-€1,200 all-in (parts + labor). Budget cars: €400-€800, premium brands: €1,200-€2,500. A universal catalytic converter saves 30-60%. At FAAY, you get a fair quote with a choice between original and universal.
How much precious metal is in catalytic converter?
An average of 2-7 grams of platinum, palladium, and rhodium. Older catalytic converters (pre-2000) contain more precious metal (up to 10 grams). Modern catalytic converters are more efficient and require less precious metal. Market value: €100-€500 depending on type and precious metal prices.
Catalytic converter problems or MOT coming up? Have your car checked at FAAY Auto Groep. We test emissions, assess your catalytic converter, and provide a fair quote (original/universal). Catalytic converter replacement starts at €320 with a 2-year warranty. APK inspection From €17.95. Call 085-0606274 or book online.
English (UK) 
Nederlands 
Français 
Polski 
Română 
Deutsch 
Русский 
Español